
The stereo Holco stepped attenuator
|
Introduction
|
With Hi-Fi Collective`s recent purchase of huge stocks of original Holsworthy 0.5W H4 Holco precision metal film resistors we felt that we had to make a stepped attenuator with them. Having catered for the high end of the market with out amazing 45 step Shallco/Shinkoh and the 24 step Elma/Shinkoh. So with the Holco`s at 25 pence each we have created a low cost superb quality stepped attenuator. We have used followed the superior series, shunt layout for the Holco stepped attenuator. It is available as a mono 23 stepped attenuator, built on the 2 pole 23 way switch with only one wafer being used, a stereo (2 channel) 23 step built on 2 pole 23 switch as illustrated in the following article or as a balanced stereo (4 channel) 23 step built on the 4 pole 23 switch. Alternatively for the more exotic option we are offering the mono 24 stepped attenuator built on an Elma 1 pole 24 way switch and finally the stereo switch built on the Elma 2 pole 24 way.
PRICE (exc. vat + carriage): available in 10K, 25K, 50K, 100K and 250K 
all prices shown below exclude VAT
Mono stepped attenuator built on the 2 pole 23 way (one layer used) - kit £24.00, built - £39.00
Stereo stepped attenuator built on the 2 pole 23 way switch - kit £32.00, built - £52.00
Balanced Stereo stepped attenuator built on the 4 pole 23 way switch - kit £56.00, built - £96.00
Mono stepped attenuator built on an Elma 1 pole 24 way - kit £43.00, built - £58.00
Stereo stepped attenuator built on an Elma 2 pole 23 way switch - kit £75.00, built - £95.00
The Hi- Fi Collective stepped attenuator is based on a shunt design where the signal is fed through a fixed series resistor, Rx and the shunt resistor, Ry, is selected from 23 values ranging from zero to infinity by means of a selector switch. See FIGURE 1. A simple ladder design has the disadvantage of having a number of resistors in the signal path. A switched ladder switches pairs of resistors as in the Dale-Vishay design, but this required two sets of switch contacts in the signal path, which is undesirable and a more complicated switch is required. Although a shunt design presents a variable input impedance to the signal source, this does not matter in practice and the benefits of a single resistor and switch in the signal path far outweighs this issue. |
Choosing the steps of attenuation
|
|
The value of attenuation for each step has been chosen to provide a fine range at low volumes, getting increasingly coarser as maximum volume is approached. Commercial stepped attenuators tend to have a 60dB range (corresponding to the Step 2 attenuation), but I have found in the past that with higher output sources, this is not quite enough. As a result, I had used the additional attenuation available in the source device, but this does adversely affect sound quality. To overcome this, I added 2 higher levels of attenuation at steps 2 and 3 and adjusted the other steps accordingly to give a smooth progression over the entire range.FIGURE 2
Resistor packs are supplied to enable 10K, 25K, 50K, 100K or 250K attenuators to be constructed. The switch itself is a 2 pole, 23 way selector switch as used in the mono Dale-Vishay stepped attenuator and uses high quality silver plated contacts and tags. The resistors are from the famous Holco range. Holco metal film precision resistors have been used in hundreds of classic high end audio components over the past twenty years. They give a crisp, full sound; about as good as it gets in a metal film type. |
Building the Attenuator
|
|
With reference to FIGURE 3, it can be seen that there is one row of 4 tags at Step 1 of the switch. The middle two tags are the wipers of the switch and correspond to the output of the attenuator. The two outer tags are the first step of each channel and are connected to the circles of wire that connects each resistor to earth. Note that there are actually 24 tags around the switch, but the 24th tag is not connected.
When building the attenuator, it should be born in mind that the integrity of Holco resistors can be disturbed with the bending of their leads close to the body so it is essential that the leads should be bent by clamping the wire near the resistor body with pliers and bending the wire on the outside see FIGURE 4 and FIGURE 5.
To build the attenuator, start by constructing the channel at the bottom of the switch as shown in FIGURE 6,FIGURE 7., FIGURE 8 and FIGURE 9. Then complete the other channel nearest the spindle FIGURE 10 and FIGURE 11.. This allows the terminals to be accessed easily and the resistors arranged neatly around the body of the switch. In each case, start with position 2 and continue around until the last resistor at position 22 is reached. Position 23 is left open circuit corresponding to zero attenuation.
Finally, connect the input series resistor to the wiper of each channel. The input of the attenuator is the input lead of the resistor and the output of the attenuator is the wiper or other end of that resistor. That completed the construction of the attenuator.
|
Testing the Attenuator
|
For this review, the attenuator was installed in the Glasshouse Passive Pre-Amplifier No.1 chassis, pls note that you can purchase this kit with the new Holco attenuator. The original pre-amp was fitted with the Dale-Vishay stepped attenuator and as the new unit is of a similar size, no difficulties were encountered with installation. Indeed, the size of the finished unit compares favourably with many high quality potentiometers and can therefore be used as a replacement for these.
For the listening tests, a variety of known recordings were played through the Glasshouse passive pre fitted with the Dale-Vishay attenuator. It performed well and gave a good performance across the range and a smooth transition between steps.
It was an easy matter to replace the Dale-Vishay unit with the new Holco attenuator and, although the Holco resistors had not been run in, I couldn't resist connecting the unit back in my system for a quick listen!
There was indeed a very marked difference. The Holcos was significantly brighter and clearer than the Dale-Vishays and it would be fair to say that, with some recordings, they did sound a touch harsh. It was time to turn off the power amplifier and leave the unit with some FM radio interstation hiss (a good source of pink noise) playing through it overnight to run in the all-important series resistors and a few of the steps but turning the volume control during the evening.
Repeating the tests the following day gave a much more polished performance. The Holco unit had retained its bright characteristic but the harshness had been tamed some what. The result was a beautiful clean and open sound, which did rather leave the Dale-Vishay sounding rather flat and ordinary.
|
Conclusion
|
FIGURE 13 shows the completed Holco attenuator fitted in the Glasshouse chassis.
All-in-all, this attenuator is a superb unit which oozes quality and will be at home installed in the finest audio equipment. designed and written by Neville Roberts
|
Resistor values of attenuator for the 2 pole 23 way switch
|
All resistors supplied are Holco 0.5W. The values listed here are ideal values and we will supply these values or as close to them as our stocks allow.
|
| |
Step Number |
10K stepped Atten.(resistor values) |
25K stepped Atten.(resistor values) |
50K stepped Atten.(resistor values) |
100K stepped Atten.(resistor values) |
250K stepped Atten.(resistor values) |
|
| | input resistor | 10K | 25K | 50K | 100K | 250K | |
| | 1 | 0R | 0R | 0R | 0R | 0R | |
| | 2 | 2R7 | 6R8 | 15R | 27R | 68R | |
| | 3 | 5R6 | 14R | 27R | 56R | 140R | |
| | 4 | 11R | 27R | 56R | 110R | 270R | |
| | 5 | 22R | 56R | 110R | 220R | 560R | |
| | 6 | 39R | 100R | 200R | 390R | 1K | |
| | 7 | 75R | 180R | 360R | 750R | 1K8 | |
| | 8 | 110R | 270R | 560R | 1K1 | 2K7 | |
| | 9 | 180R | 470R | 910R | 1K8 | 4K7 | |
| | 10 | 240R | 620R | 1K3 | 2K4 | 6K2 | |
| | 11 | 360R | 910R | 1K8 | 3K6 | 9K1 | |
| | 12 | 510R | 1K3 | 2K7 | 5K1 | 13K | |
| | 13 | 750R | 1K8 | 3K9 | 7K5 | 18K | |
| | 14 | 1K1 | 2K7 | 5K6 | 11K | 27K | |
| | 15 | 1K6 | 4K3 | 8K2 | 16K | 43K | |
| | 16 | 2K4 | 6K2 | 12K | 24K | 62K | |
| | 17 | 3K3 | 8K2 | 16K | 33K | 82K | |
| | 18 | 4K7 | 12K | 24K | 47K | 120K | |
| | 19 | 6K8 | 16K | 33K | 68K | 160K | |
| | 20 | 10K | 24K | 51K | 100K | 240K | |
| | 21 | 18K | 43K | 82K | 180K | 430K | |
| | 22 | 39K | 100K | 180K | 390K | 1M | |
| | 23 | Infinity | Infinity | Infinity | Infinity | Infinity | |
Resistor values of attenuator for the Elma 2 pole 24 way switch
|
All resistors supplied will be Holco 0.5W however on the very low R values that are involved in the first 3/4 steps we may supply resistors in parallel with one being a 1W H2 holcos, occasionally we may supply Shinkohs at no additional cost to yourself. Sorry about this but low value Holcos are very rare. The values listed here are ideal values and we will supply these values or as close to them as our stocks allow.
|
| |
Step Number |
10K stepped Atten.(resistor values) |
25K stepped Atten.(resistor values) |
50K stepped Atten.(resistor values) |
100K stepped Atten.(resistor values) |
250K stepped Atten.(resistor values) |
|
| | input resistor | 10K | 25K | 50K | 100K | 250K | |
| | 1 | 0R | 0R | 0R | 0R | 0R | |
| | 2 | 2R | 4R | 9R1 | 18R | 44R | |
| | 3 | 3R6 | 9R | 18R | 36R | 91R | |
| | 4 | 6R8 | 18R | 36R | 68R | 180R | |
| | 5 | 13R | 33R | 62R | 130R | 330R | |
| | 6 | 22R | 56R | 110R | 220R | 560R | |
| | 7 | 39R | 100R | 200R | 390R | 1K | |
| | 8 | 68R | 180R | 360R | 680R | 1K8 | |
| | 9 | 110R | 270R | 560R | 1K1 | 2K7 | |
| | 10 | 180R | 470R | 910R | 1K8 | 4K7 | |
| | 11 | 270R | 620R | 1K3 | 2K4 | 6K2 | |
| | 12 | 360R | 910R | 1K8 | 3K6 | 9K1 | |
| | 13 | 510R | 1K3 | 2K7 | 5K1 | 13K | |
| | 14 | 750R | 1K8 | 3K9 | 7K5 | 18K | |
| | 15 | 1K1 | 2K7 | 5K6 | 11K | 27K | |
| | 16 | 1K6 | 4K3 | 8K2 | 16K | 43K | |
| | 17 | 2K4 | 6K2 | 12K | 24K | 62K | |
| | 18 | 3K3 | 8K2 | 18K | 33K | 82K | |
| | 19 | 4K7 | 12K | 24K | 47K | 120K | |
| | 20 | 6K8 | 16K | 33K | 68K | 160K | |
| | 21 | 10K | 24K | 51K | 100K | 240K | |
| | 22 | 18K | 43K | 91K | 180K | 430K | |
| | 23 | 36K | 100K | 200K | 390K | 1M | |
| | 24 | Infinity | Infinity | Infinity | Infinity | Infinity | |
PARTS LIST for Holco stepped attenuator kits
|
Mono Holco stepped attenuator on 2 pole 23 way switch (one layer of switch unused) PRICE: kit - £24.00, built - £39.00
- 2 pole 23 way switch
- 21 off Holco resistors
- 0.25m off 1mm diameter HGC 99.99% silver wire
- 1m off Mundorf 3.8% silver solder
Stereo Holco stepped attenuator on 2 pole 23 way switch PRICE: kit - £32.00, built - £52.00
- 2 pole 23 way switch
- 42 off Holco resistors
- 0.5m off 1mm diameter HGC 99.99% silver wire
- 1m off Mundorf 3.8% silver solder
Balanced stereo Holco stepped attenuator on 4 pole 23 way switch PRICE: kit - £56.00, built - £96.00
- 4 pole 23 way switch
- 84 off Holco resistors
- 1m off 1mm diameter HGC 99.99% silver wire
- 2m off Mundorf 3.8% silver solder
Mono Holco stepped attenuator on Elma 1 pole 24 way switch PRICE: kit - £43.00, built - £58.00
- Elma 1 pole 24 way switch
- 22 off Holco resistors
- 0.25m off 1mm diameter HGC 99.99% silver wire
- 1m off Mundorf 3.8% silver solder
Stereo Holco stepped attenuator on Elma 2 pole 24 way switch PRICE: kit - £75.00, built - £95.00
- Elma 2 pole 24 way switch
- 44 off Holco resistors
- 0.5m off 1mm diameter HGC 99.99% silver wire
- 1m off Mundorf 3.8% silver solder
|
TOOLS REQUIRED
|
- Soldering iron
- Trimming knife
- Snipe nose pliars
- Cutters
all the above are available in the tools section of the hificollective shop.
|
|